Not Every Attack Is Punishment: The Grounding of Trusting God
“Is God punishing me?”
A man sat quietly in a hospital room staring out the window. A few months earlier, life had been moving in the right direction. He was working hard, praying faithfully, serving others, and doing his best to walk with God. Then, seemingly all at once, everything began to unravel. His health declined. His finances tightened. Relationships became strained. Doors he had prayed would open remained shut. As we talked, he shared the questions others had been asking him.
“What did you do?”
“Is God trying to tell you something?”
“Have you examined your life?”
Beneath every question was the same assumption: if life is falling apart, God must be punishing you.
As a chaplain, I hear some version of these questions regularly in hospital rooms, waiting areas, and quiet hallways.
“What did I do to deserve this?”
“Why is God allowing this?”
“Is God punishing me?”
I’ve heard them from grieving spouses, frightened parents, and faithful believers facing diagnoses they never expected. I’ve heard them from people who love God deeply and cannot understand why suffering has entered their lives. And if I’m honest, I’ve asked some of those questions myself. But I have also grown to understand that scripture teaches that sin has consequences. It also teaches something many believers forget: not every attack is punishment.
Consequences Are Real, But Not the Only Explanation
The Word of God does not ignore the reality of consequences. Proverbs 6:12-15 warns that those who continually sow evil eventually reap the fruit of their actions. Hebrews 12 reminds us that God disciplines those He loves. To put it differently, sometimes suffering is connected to our choices and sometimes God allows discomfort to redirect us, refine us, or reveal areas of our lives that need surrender.
C.S. Lewis famously described pain as “God’s megaphone.” He suggests that when life is comfortable, we can become spiritually inattentive and pain often forces us to pay attention. That is why David prayed, “Search me, O God, and know my heart…” (Psalm 139:23) leading us to awareness with God:
● Self-examination is biblical.
● Repentance is biblical.
● Humility is biblical.
But there is a difference between allowing God to search our hearts and assuming every hardship is evidence of His displeasure.
Human Eyes Are Poor Judges
The longer I serve in ministry, the more convinced I become that human beings are sometimes poor judges of spiritual realities. We see suffering and assume failure, and we see prosperity and assume blessing. Yet Scripture repeatedly reminds us that what we see is rarely the whole story.
Asaph wrestled with this in Psalm 73 when he looked at the prosperity of the wicked and wondered why the faithful seemed to suffer.
Samuel nearly made the same mistake when he was sent to anoint Israel’s future king. Looking at Jesse’s sons, he was impressed by what he saw. But God stopped him and said, “Do not consider his appearance or his height, for I have rejected him. The Lord does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks at the heart.” (1 Samuel 16:7)
Before we draw conclusions about another person’s suffering, blessing, or spiritual condition, we would do well to remember that only God sees the whole story.
Job: When Heaven Sees Warfare
If there is one biblical story that challenges our assumptions about suffering, it is the story of Job. Before Job ever experiences loss on earth, there is a conversation taking place in heaven. While Job’s friends later see suffering, God sees faithfulness.
“Have you considered My servant Job?” God asks (Job 1:8)
It is immediately after that commendation that the attacks begin. Think about that for a moment. The battle was not happening because Job was far from God. The battle was happening because Job was close to Him. Yet Job’s friends could not see what was happening behind the scenes. They looked at his losses and concluded he must be hiding some terrible sin.
The were wrong!
As readers, we know something they did not know: Heaven saw warfare where human beings saw judgment. Job reminds us that not every battle originates in disobedience:
Sometimes suffering is not evidence that God has abandoned us.
Sometimes it is evidence that the story is bigger than what human eyes can see.
John 9: The Wrong Question
The disciples were not immune to this way of thinking. In fact, when they encountered a man born blind, they immediately asked Jesus, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” (John 9:2). Based on the human lens, let’s normalize this. It is such a human question. We see suffering and instinctively begin looking for someone to blame, but Jesus rejected the premise altogether.
“Neither this man nor his parents sinned, but that the works of God should be revealed in him.” (John 9:3)
The disciples were focused on blame.
Jesus was focused on purpose.
John 9 demonstrates a poignant lesson: Sometimes the wrong question keeps us from seeing what God is trying to reveal.
Calvary: The Ultimate Misreading
Perhaps the clearest example of this misunderstanding is found at Calvary. The cross was a living tableau that summed up the errors in judgment humanity too often makes, which at times can be wounding, even lethal. Calvary’s misunderstanding revealed that Jesus was not merely suffering. He was being judged by public opinion:
The religious leaders accused Him of blasphemy.
False witnesses testified against Him.
He was mocked, condemned, and executed under charges that portrayed Him as a criminal and an enemy of God.
To those watching, His death appeared to confirm the accusations. After all, He hung between two thieves. That is proof enough! Nevertheless, Isaiah foretold this misunderstanding centuries earlier:
“Yet we esteemed Him stricken, smitten by God, and afflicted” (Isaiah 53:4).
Notice the language…
We esteemed Him.
We considered Him.
We concluded.
Thus, the people watching believed God was punishing Him. Yet Isaiah immediately corrects that conclusion:
“But he was pierced for our transgressions, he was crushed for our iniquities; the punishment that brought us peace was on him, and by his wounds we are healed” (Isaiah 53:5).
The invitation here is to see what is essential to the mindfulness we must practice when assessing suffering. What appeared to be punishment for Jesus’ sins was actually suffering on behalf of others. Luke records one thief acknowledging the difference:
“We are punished justly, for we are getting what our deeds deserve. But this man has done nothing wrong.” (Luke 23:41).
There on Golgotha stood three crosses.
Two men were suffering because of their crimes.
One Man was suffering despite His innocence.
If people could look at the sinless Son of God hanging on a cross and conclude that His suffering proved His guilt, how careful should we be when interpreting the suffering of others?
Warfare Is Still Real
The story does not end with Job, the blind man, or even Calvary. Jesus told Peter, “…Satan has asked for you, that he may sift you as wheat.” (Luke 22:31). Indeed Peter was tested, but he was not abandoned. Revelation 12:17 describes the dragon making war against those who remain faithful to God.
Author Ellen G. White repeatedly emphasized this reality in her writings on the “Great Controversy.” God’s faithful people often found themselves opposed not because they were forsaken by God, but because they remained loyal to Him.
Simply put, sometimes the battle has less to do with what you have done and more to do with whose you are.
The Grounding of Trusting God
We cannot explain away suffering. Nor is it an excuse to avoid repentance. When hardship comes, it is appropriate to pray David’s prayer: “Search me, O God, and know my heart” (Psalm 139:23).
Ministering throughout the years, I have sat with people whose faithfulness does not appear to be producing ease. Instead, they find themselves wrestling not only with physical pain, but also with emotional, mental, and spiritual suffering. I
Those moments can be deeply confusing. I know because I have wrestled with these myself….we all have. And when suffering refuses to fit neatly into our theology, we begin searching for answers. We compare our stories with the stories of others. We look for causes, for explanations and yes, we wonder whether God is trying to tell us something. This desire to understand suffering is deeply human. The problem is that sometimes our search for answers leads us to conclusions that God Himself has not made.
However, the stories of Job, the man born blind, Peter, and even Jesus remind us that suffering cannot always be explained by simple formulas. Sometimes it reveals consequences. Sometimes it reveals discipline. Sometimes it reflects the painful reality of living in a broken world. And sometimes it is evidence that the enemy has taken notice of a life that belongs to God. Simply put, sometimes the battle has less to do with what you have done and more to do with whose you are.
Job never received an explanation for everything he endured. Instead, God revealed Himself. And somehow, that became enough. That’s why he said: “Though He slay me, yet will I trust Him” (Job 13:15).
In his awareness, reflection, introspect, and grounding Job invites us to mindset shifts. Self-examination is healthy. Self-condemnation is not. And with that processing, defaulting to trusting God. That is the posture of faith, not understanding everything, yet trusting the God who does.
Our daily “sound mind” reminder should be moving forward…not every attack is a punishment.
The battle is real.
But so is God.




