Donnie Swaggart’s Presumption to Correct the Black Church

Multicolored stained glass window with irregular random block pattern
image_pdfimage_print

On October 13, 2024, Pastor Donnie Swaggart mounted the pulpit of the The Family Worship Center, (Baton Rouge, LA), a church he inherited from his father. He announced the title of his sermon as, “Speak Now, Or Forever Lose Your Freedom”, using Ephesians 5:11-17 and Esther 4:13,14 as his texts.

It was a curious amalgam of scriptures – the first being an admonishment to walk in the light, while also exposing those who don’t, conflated with Mordecai’s demand that Queen Esther speak up on behalf of the Jews in Persia.

Admirably, Swaggart began by decrying the sins of slavery and racism in the U.S., and how it was preachers who stood in support of Abraham Lincoln when the nation seemed unwilling to confront those evils. Using this as a pretext, Swaggart began to vigorously assert that preachers had to speak out against perceived wrongs in order to save the nation – just as they did back in the days of legalized chattel slavery.Then Swaggart veered sharply.

Making reference to the recent endorsement of Vice President Kamala Harris by the leader of the Church Of God In Christ (COGIC), Presiding Bishop J. Drew Sheard, Swaggart launched a broadside reprimand against the collective Black Church, saying…

…somebody needs to stand up and speak to the black church – when the largest African American Pentecostal denomination, when that leader stands up and said ‘I endorse that woman (Harris)’, he was saying, ‘I endorse murder, I endorse homosexuality, I endorse lesbianism, I endorse transgenderism, I endorse every evil that Hell could prosper…’

Since delivering that sermon, Swaggart has now become the target of a massive pushback, with preachers, among others, calling him a racist. Calling Swaggart a “racist” is simply low-hanging fruit, and misses the broader, deeper points. His words were reflective of matters that are bigger than just one man (him), and issues that require a more sophisticated parsing.

So, let’s dig deeper!

The Legacy of Racial Paternalism

First, a little background, Swaggart’s church claims to be non-denominational, but its background is actually rooted in the Assemblies Of God (AOG), a Pentecostal denomination. The AOG was almost exclusively white at its beginning, but it didn’t start out that way.  It actually grew out of the predominantly Black COGIC fellowship. Racism and Jim Crow discrimination ultimately led to the AOG Church becoming a predominantly white, alternate expression of Pentecostalism.

This was the early 1900’s, and racism and bigotry allowed the AOG Church to flourish. Conversely, its black counterpart – the COGIC Church – struggled. Ultimately, reflecting the prevailing racism of the times, the AOG actually took on racist principles, forbidding the ordination of black ministers from 1939-1962. Still, many of these white Pentecostals presumed it to be their duty to help the poorer black members of their movement – not as equals, but as inferiors, whom they were obliged to serve as a matter of mission and duty.

No matter how well-intended, this sort of mindset produces a paternalism that may serve others, but condescendingly so. It is based on a sense of superiority that presumes to know what’s better for others. It fails to recognize that those to whom they condescend to serve are innately their equals. It is the mindset that allowed slaveowners to perceive that they were a blessing to their enslaved. It is a mindset that allowed colonizing Europeans to see themselves as the saviors of Africa – even as they exploit it and her people.

This was the environment that nurtured Donnie Swaggart.

So when Swaggart launched his scathing rebuke against Sheard and the COGIC community, he may have been acting out of a self-perceived benevolence! This was noblesse oblige at its finest; somebody needed to save the poor, black brethren from their ignorance; and, Donnie Swaggart decided it might as well be him.

The Curse of a Narrow Bible Perspective

The foundation of Swaggart’s reprimand was what he perceived to be a need to call out sin. Most specifically, he targeted the favorite twin targets of today’s conservative Christian: Homosexuality and Abortion. Apparently, to them the apex of God’s anger is reached when same-sex couples hold hands, or when a fetus is not allowed to be born. For many of these folks the Bible gets narrowed to speaking solely about Pro-Life issues, and His opprobrium towards anything that they perceive to be against Biblical heteronormality (i.e., sexual attraction only between a male and a female).

The conservative Christian focus on protecting the unborn is founded on passages like the following:

“Before I formed you in the womb I knew you…” (Jeremiah 1:5)

“My frame was not hidden from You, when I was made in secret…” (Psalm 139:15)

But both of those passages are focused more on the foreknowledge of God, rather than definitively declaring when life begins. In fact, they allude to the fact that from God’s perspective one’s life might begin before conception – “before you were formed… I knew you!” God asserts.

Next on the conservative agenda is the preoccupation with homosexuality. Their convictions are based on certain biblical passages that seem to express God’s ideal intention – that of a man and a woman, producing children. But the ideals of God crashed long ago into the failures of humankind, and God found a way to allow that which may not have been originally intended. Abraham had two wives, and Jacob had four! Daniel and his companions found themselves unmarried, and in the company of eunuchs in Babylon. Divorce – though never intended by God – became allowable due to human intransigence. In fact, the issue of sexual identity was only broached once by Jesus in Matthew 19 (vss 11,12); yet some find a way to make this a central feature of the Bible!

It’s not that these conservative Christians are wrong in debating these matters, and developing convictions regarding what they believe God requires. What makes them wrong is when they determine that their convictions are absolute, and everybody has to go along with their beliefs. TheirAct justly, love mercy and walk humbly with your God, Micah 6:8. Bible quote, hand-lettering willingness to enforce their standards upon the consciences of others is coercive, and more reflective of that beastly power revealed in Revelations 13 (it “orders” vs 14, it “causes” vs 15, it “forces” vs 16).

Worse still, their focus on those two items allows them to neglect other “weightier matters” (according to Jesus) like “justice, mercy and faith” (Matthew 23:23). They walk right by Micah’s inspired apotheosis of godliness,

He has shown you, O man, what is good; and what does the Lord require of you, but to do justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God? (Micah 6:8)

…and they disregard the apostolic recipe for good religion –

Pure and undefiled religion before God and the Father is this: to visit orphans and widows in their trouble, and to keep oneself unspotted from the world. (James 1:27)

They arrogantly demand that others hew to their demands, as they narrowly define the requirements of God. As the Rev. Dr. William Barber, a recognized voice for justice and equality, states, “they say so much about what God says so little, and so little about what God says so much.”

As the Rev. Dr. William Barber, a recognized voice for justice and equality, states, “they say so much about what God says so little, and so little about what God says so much.”

The Primacy of Peacemaking

When there is an offense, or a perceived wrong, we are admonished to try to resolve things within the smallest circle possible. In Matthew 18 Jesus tells us to confront an offending party one-on-one, and if that fails, to take another person to help resolve things (vss 15,16). The idea is to try to keep the peace, and to thereby allow for unity.

Donnie Swaggart failed in that regard. Instead of seeking to create a dialogue that might offer understanding – and hopefully healing – he raised a national bullhorn to his lips and offered words of condemnation. His words served to stir up dissention and rancor, rather than peace and unity.

A real opportunity at peacemaking was missed here. One can only imagine what might have occurred if Swaggart had picked up a phone, and in the spirit of peace, called to converse privately with Bishop Sheard; what unity might have been created?

Donnie Swaggart may not be a racist, but his words can be used to aid and abet the aims of racists. And unfortunately, the one thing he got right in his sermon was when he said, “they’re gonna call me a racist…”

But it does us no good to repeat his mistakes, and to hurl invectives at him in anger. We are still called to seek healing, and to promote peace. It may be easy to simply call Donnie Swaggart a “racist,” but we are not called to do easy things! We are called to be “repairers of breaches,” and peacemakers.

We are called to love, even when it is difficult. Even if the person we are called to love is Donnie Swaggart.

More from W. Nick Taliaferro
Truth Tuesday: The Forbidden Fruit of Lust
Views: 1,394No matter what we do in life, there will be times...
Read More
Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.