The Silence of the Lambs

Sad concerned Black teenage girl thinking over problems
image_pdfimage_print

Allegations surfaced last week regarding a young woman who says she was drugged and sexually assaulted at a Cornell University fraternity house. Two years later, the case is back in the news, not only because of what she alleged happened, but because of questions about what happened after she spoke. New York appointed a special prosecutor, reopening a larger conversation about sexual violence, institutional responsibility, and systems that appear to fail those they should protect. Cornell’s 2025 survey found that 35% of undergraduate women reported experiencing nonconsensual sexual contact since enrolling.

That’s one story. Across the country another victim’s story surfaced after she disclosed physical and sexual abuse by her father. Her teacher, as a mandated reporter, gave voice to this young survivor.

The Silencing of the Lambs is Not New

From biblical days we have read, maybe too quickly, the silencing of the lambs, the innocent ones, God’s children. Tamar, David’s daughter, was violated by her brother Amnon, then told, “Be quiet for now, my sister” (2 Samuel 13:20). She had already been violated, and then came the silence.

There was Tamar, Judah’s daughter-in-law, whose future was controlled by the men around her until Judah finally confessed, “She is more righteous than I” (Genesis 38:26).

There was Bathsheba, summoned by a king whose power reached into her home.

There was the Levite’s concubine in Judges 19, handed over, brutalized, and left without protection.

And those are only the stories of scripture preserved. How many stories were never written? How many names did history forget? How many screams disappeared with the people who heard them?

When the Body Was Property

For black people in America, this history has another chapter that cannot be ignored. Before hashtags, university investigations, church committees, hotlines, and reporting policies, black bodies were legally treated as property. Sexual violence against enslaved people was used to control bodies, terrorize families, and enforce power. Enslaved black women especially had little legal protection or recourse. That matters because you cannot understand today’s silence without remembering yesterday’s permission.

Harriet Jacobs left us one testimony of what that meant. She endured years of sexual harassment from the man who enslaved her before she escaped. Her body was not considered her own. Her “no” did not have the protection of law. Moreover, the violence did not disappear with emancipation. Black women continued living at the intersection of racism, sexism, sexual violence, and disbelief. Yet they resisted. They testified. They organized. They spoke.

Ida B. Wells understood the power of truth when she wrote, “The way to right wrongs is to turn the light of truth upon them.”
Long before #MeToo, black women were saying: This happened to me.
Different stories, but the same wound of power.

When Silence Got a Name

Sometimes part of breaking silence is finally having language for what happened. In 1975, former Cornell employee Carmita Wood sought help after years of unwanted sexual advances from her supervisor. She connected with Lin Farley, Susan Meyer, and Karen Sauvigné, women associated with Cornell’s Human Affairs Program, who searched for words to describe what Wood and so many other women were experiencing. The words they settled on were sexual harassment. Cornell’s own archives credit Farley with coining the phrase.

That same year, women gathered in Ithaca for a “Speak Out” and began telling stories that had existed long before the language did. Farley testified publicly about the issue before the New York City Commission on Human Rights. Five years later, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) formally recognized sexual harassment as sex discrimination under Title VII; in 1986, the Supreme Court affirmed that it could violate federal civil-rights law.

Think about the irony.
Fifty years ago, women at Cornell helped America name the silence.
And today, Cornell has again become part of a national conversation about what happens when a woman says:
This happened to me.

Different Stories. Same Wound of Power

That history brings us to now.

WNBA rookie Justine Pissott has spoken publicly about surviving sexual assault. Layshia Clarendon alleged sexual assault by someone in their college athletic environment whom they trusted. Breanna Stewart shared that she was sexually abused for two years beginning when she was nine. Different ages. Different abuses. But the same wound of power.

The Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN) reports that 1 in 8 students experiences sexual violence during college, and 2 in 5 report sexual harassment. Cornell is not only one story. It is a doorway into a larger one.

Close to Home 

Some within our institutions have spoken. Some are speaking now. Some still cannot speak on our campuses whether secular, public, private, even faith-based campuses.  Our black and brown children who go to school for an education and leave being educated in trauma, disrespect, violation, and silence, their life trajectory now carrying another component: survivor.

We have our children in homes, schools, churches, workplaces, ministries, and offices, placed in so-called safe spaces only to discover they may be the most unsafe spaces in the world.

When Safe Places Become Unsafe

The workplace belongs in this conversation. Harassment is abuse too. Sexual harassment. Bullying. Discrimination. Intimidation. Retaliation. Career sabotage. Sometimes abuse is a thousand small cuts: a complaint unanswered, an opportunity disappearing, a supervisor treating you differently because you spoke.

The EEOC reports that roughly three out of four people who experience harassment never speak to a supervisor, manager, or union representative, often fearing disbelief, inaction, blame, or retaliation. Sometimes your dignity, livelihood, reputation, and safety are assaulted until your body remembers what the institution conveniently forgets.

Female Clergy

And, a word for female clergy? Instead of enjoying their calling are sitting in a therapy chair, taking medications, or still questioning what happened. Research on clergywomen and occupational distress and on sexism and sexual harassment among African American women in the church gives language to what too many have carried in silence. Those not believed. Those not chosen because of gender, tenure, friendships, or because they were not part of the good old boys’ club. Those who gave years to a calling from God, only to carry wounds.

We see you. We hear your silent cries. Your calling is not diminished by what happened to you.

Where Do You Stand With God?

Desmond Tutu warned, “If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor.”

So if you knew, saw, were told, were cried to, were asked for help, and walked away, I ask you:
Where do you think you stand with God? With, or against the “least of these?”
Jesus said, “Whatever you did for one of the least of these… you did for me” (Matthew 25:40).

The Truth

The truth is you can still speak up. You can course correct. You can advocate.
The way is to speak. If you are in a place of power, follow justice: “Learn to do right; seek justice. Defend the oppressed” (Isaiah 1:17).
And the life? You may save one. Maybe, in doing what is right, you save something in yourself too—your conscience, integrity, relationship with God. Paul told Timothy, “Watch your life and doctrine closely. Persevere in them, because if you do, you will save both yourself and your hearers” (1 Timothy 4:16).

Biblical restoration begins with truth, repentance, responsibility, and changed behavior. It does not mean returning someone to power, access, or trust simply because they apologized. Paul says those who are spiritual should seek restoration gently (Galatians 6:1), but restoration is never pretending nothing happened.

Furthermore, grace is not the absence of accountability. Restoration is not reinstatement. Forgiveness is not permission. Mercy is not silence. Abuse destroys.

Silence protects the destruction. Truth interrupts it. Justice protects the vulnerable. Genuine repentance accepts the cost of repair.

For The Little Lambs

Maybe that is where we begin, with the little lambs whose innocence was stolen, who tried to tell us, whom nobody believed, whose stories were buried beneath reputations, titles, pulpits, careers, and institutions.

Some of those lambs have names we know. Some do not.
Some are identified only by a pseudonym because even telling the truth can come with a cost. Just like the young woman at the center of the Cornell case, identified publicly as Jane Doe. Her name may be hidden in court documents, but her humanity is not. Moreover, her story has reopened questions about what happened after she reported what she says was done to her, and about what institutions do when a survivor speaks.

The courts will determine legal responsibility. Investigations will examine evidence. Institutions will answer for what they did or failed to do. But none of that requires us to withhold compassion from the person who says she was harmed.

And this is for the little lambs who have been silenced: We lambs who have been given our voice back will forever speak for you!
If you or someone you know has experienced sexual violence, confidential support is available through the RAINN National Sexual Assault Hotline.

 

 

Sources
Aces’ Justine Pissott Opens Up About Her Sexual Assault Amid Cornell ‘7’ Uproar — People

Black Pastors’ Experiences of Occupational and Life Stress During COVID-19 in the USA

Black History Month and Sexual Violence

Dealing with Institutional Sexism: The Coping Strategies of Hong Kong Clergywomen

Desmond Tutu on Neutrality in Situations of Injustice — Desmond & Leah Tutu Legacy Foundation

Ida B. Wells and “The Way to Right Wrongs Is to Turn the Light of Truth Upon Them” — Library of Congress

Layshia Clarendon Alleges Sexual Assault by UC Berkeley Employee — Los Angeles Times

Me Too — Breanna Stewart, The Players’ Tribune

Part 1 – Sexual Violence Against African American Slaves and Its Legacy Today

RAINN National Sexual Assault Hotline — Help and Healing

Sexism and Sexual Harassment: Concerns of African American Women of the Christian Methodist Episcopal Church

Sexual Violence — From Naming to Knowing

Sexual Exploitation of Black Women From the Years 1619–2020

The Resilience of Clergywomen? Gender and the Relationship between Occupational Distress and Mental Health among Congregational Leaders

What We Know About the Cornell University Rape Investigation — Reuters

More from Latoya Hazell-Alcide
Politics of the World and God’s Kingdom
Views: 1,285Ah, Politics! Who needs soap operas when politics today is serving...
Read More
Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.