Bogus St. Patrick’s Day Legends and What We Can Memorialize

shamrock gold rainbow irish st patrick

Being born on March 17, and having an Irish surname leads me to have more reflections and conversations about St. Patrick’s Day than the average person, as I wrote two years ago. This time we’re going to look at some of the myths related to the man, St. Patrick.


Legend has it that British-born St. Patrick used a shamrock to teach Irish pagans about the trinity. However, there’s a few problems with this:

1) The word shamrock doesn’t come into use until a thousand years after St. Patrick’s death and it took nearly as long for this legend to develop.
2) There’s disagreement on if there actually is such a thing as a shamrock and, if it they exist, if they’re capable of growing in non-Irish soil.
3) Most significantly, St. Patrick never alludes to anything like this in his only two extant writings, the Confessio and the Epistola. Aside from these two documents, we really don’t know anything else about Ireland’s British Bishop.


Ever heard about St. Patrick chasing all the snakes out of Ireland? Uh-uh. Nope. Didn’t happen since the island never had snakes. And, again, he never wrote anything about chasing, killing, or even screaming and running away from snakes. Nobody mentions this legend until 600 years after the approximate date of his death.

And, about that date. March 17 is said to be St. Patrick’s date of death, not birth. Nobody recorded the date, it just showed up on liturgical calendar centuries later.


Patrick’s father had a successful business, enriched by slave labor. Ironically, Patrick was kidnapped from Britain and sold into slavery in Ireland at age 16. After six-years-a-slave, Patrick escaped back to Britain. He trained for the ministry and dreamed that God was calling him to go back to preach in Ireland. He was enslaved again for a short period of time, but Patrick refused to be deterred from his purpose, describing himself as being bound by the Spirit to minister in the land of his captivity.

Souls over Gold

As soon as Valentine’s Day ends, naked cupids are displaced by leprechauns (clothed, thankfully) on retail shelves. Is this a case of Roman icons being gentrified by Irish ones? Anyway, the clever little creatures with pots of gold at the end of rainbows have nothing to do with St. Patrick. This saint developed a love for souls over gold and argued for people to be prized over possessions.

St. Patrick wrote his fiery Epistola as a call for repentance and reparations from those who had killed, enslaved, and sold women and men he had just baptized and anointed. In doing so, he was putting his life on the line for a wholistic ministry. He wasn’t satisfied with people’s soul’s being saved while their bodies were in bondage:

It is not that I would choose to let anything so blunt and harsh come from my mouth, but I am driven by the zeal for God. And the truth of Christ stimulates me, for love of neighbors and children: for these, I have given up my homeland and my parents, and my very life to death…

The Most High does not accept the gifts of evildoers. The one who offers a sacrifice taken from what belongs to the poor is like one who sacrifices a child in the very sight of the child’s father. Riches, says Scripture, which a person gathers unjustly, will be vomited out of that person’s stomach. The angel of death will drag such a one away, to be crushed by the anger of dragons.

St. Patrick continued by urging his followers to resist flattering these traffickers and to boycott them instead:

[A]ll the holy and humble of heart should not fawn on such people, nor even share food or drink with them, nor accept their alms, until such time as they make satisfaction to God in severe penance and shedding of tears, and until they set free the men-servants of God and the baptised women servants of Christ, for whom he died and was crucified.

Shouldn’t commemorations of St. Patrick’s legacy set higher goals than wearing green clothes, eating green cookies and cupcakes, and turning rivers green for a day? Why not draft modern versions of the Epistola, instead of getting drunk on green beer?

This article originally appeared in on March, 8, 2023.


Written By
More from Carl McRoy
When A Black Man is Born to an Irish Mother on St. Patrick’s Day
Views: 1 Luck of the Smoked Irish I am Black. How do...
Read More
Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.